Hunter Strategies LLC logo

Microsoft News Tracker

What's more interesting than observing Microsoft?

April 25, 2006

Hope for Microsoft at EU trial?

Posted by David Hunter at 9:31 AM ET.

If, like me, you aren’t overly familiar with the personalities and procedures of European Union jurisprudence, James Kanter has an eye opening article in today’s NY Times about the Court of First Instance where this week’s Microsoft antitrust appeal is being heard. The net is that the court is rather skeptical of the antitrust bureaucrats at the European Commission and regarded as pro-business:

In a series of recent cases, the court, which is hearing Microsoft’s appeal in its antitrust case this week, has chastised European Union officials, accusing them of using inadequate evidence to bar mergers, impose fines and force companies to share their intellectual property. Last December, it upheld a decision to block a proposed $42 billion merger between two other United States companies, General Electric and Honeywell International. But it also scolded European officials for making errors and it raised the bar on similar cases in the future.

Some lawyers say the court’s emergence as a check on overzealous European Union officials was long overdue, but some also worry that the regulators have become afraid to do their jobs aggressively, fearing the stigma of another defeat.

In recent cases, the court has saved companies hundreds of millions of euros by reducing fines for their involvement in cartels and for their attempts to block trade across national borders. European regulators have also made U-turns, like abandoning plans to block the purchase of P&O Princess Cruises of Britain by the United States cruise ship company Carnival in 2002.

Court scrutiny has left “the commission rocking back on its heels,” said Richard Wainwright, the head of the European Union commission’s team of competition lawyers until 2005 and now a London-based consultant with the law firm Allen & Overy.

More by following the link including speculation about why the full court removed the Microsoft case from the sole jurisdiction of a judge who has been critical of the court for “favoring business over society.” Closer:

“We already know that many of the judges, and President Vesterdorf in particular, are no longer willing to take E.U. officials’ stories of how they reached their conclusions at face value.”

Maybe there’s light for Microsoft at the end of the EU tunnel?

Filed under Antitrust, General Business, Governmental Relations, Legal, Microsoft

Related posts:


One Response to “Hope for Microsoft at EU trial?”

  1. EU to impose Microsoft fines? -- Microsoft News Tracker Says:

    [...] “Microsoft has complied fully with every instruction given by the commission,” the company said in an e-mailed statement. “Any fine would be unjustified and unnecessary.’’ … “Microsoft has committed massive resources to the technical documentation program following the guidance provided by the trustee in April of this year, and has already delivered five of seven installments of technical documentation developed to the agreed specification and according to the agreed work plan,’’ Microsoft’s statement said. “The next two installments will be submitted on June 30 and July 18 and Microsoft is working hard to also meet those deadlines.’’ Note that this is separate from Microsoft’s April proceeding before the European Court of First Instance which, if completely successful, would invalidate all of the EC’s decisions including the fine. [...]

News Search:

Recent Posts:

Daily Digest Email:

Enter your Email

Powered by FeedBlitz


Full category list


Archive List

RSS Feed:

HunterStrat Links:


  • Powered by WordPress.